Friday 21 November 2014

Do Electronic Insect Repellents Work

Mosquitos and other insects ignore electronic repellants.


Manufacturers of electronic insect repelling devices claim their products scare away bugs through noise. The noises cannot be heard by people but are purported to be incredibly irritating to insects such as mosquitoes, cockroaches, ants, fleas, spiders and flies. Does this Spark an idea?


Studies


Studies of the use of electronic devices to repel mosquitoes and German cockroaches have concluded that ultrasonic or electromagnetic noise is ineffective. The insects ignored the noise.


Controversy


Electronic mosquito repellents are sold on airplanes to tourists going to countries with malaria despite lack of scientific backing. In 2010, KLM Royal Dutch Airline became the first airline to stop selling the devices.


Challenge and Defiance


In 2001, the Federal Trade Commission sent warnings to 60 makers of so-called electronic insect repellents, telling them that their claims must be supported by scientific evidence. Despite the warning and the absence of such evidence, the manufacture and marketing of such devices continues.

Tags: